
It is clear that the UK Green Party has now been joined by a large group of voters who would describe themselves as “left wing.” As a lifelong supporter of Green politics (though I’ve never voted for the Green Party) I am of course very pleased that they now have a leader with some charisma and a good clear message, but I am also concerned that they now clearly espouse what I call “urban” values and are in danger of losing sight of what should be their core set of values which I call “natural.”
For example, I have recently been reading “Vulture Capitalism” by Grace Blakely, a young woman who has recently joined the Green Party, having previously been a supporter of Jermey Corbyn. The book is an attack on Corporate Greed and she sees neo-liberalism as the means by which the corporations and their state backers have stolen power from the workers. In other words it’s classic Marxism – the world we live in is a battle between the workers and the owners of capital (our essential resources such as land, minerals, housing, machinery, transport etc.)
Although the enemy might be the same, this is peripheral to the core of Green politics which should be about the growing threat to the survival of our species and of all life on earth which is due, not just to our rising carbon-dioxide emissions but to our over-use of all our essential resources such as water and fertile land as well as fossil fuel.
While the urban left is arguing about gender, and “inclusion” those with the money – the capital – are gaining ever-increasing power over our lives. The growth of Artificial Intelligence has led to a huge increase in the burning of fossil fuel. No amount of COP conferences, heat pumps, wind turbines, electric cars and emission-free zones are going to stall global heating because those with the power are already planning to colonise other planets when ours is no longer fit to live in.
What Green politics should be shouting about is radical indeed, but it’s not the workers versus the capitalists, it’s the whole system – the demand economy. Look at the way we in the affluent countries live – we travel everywhere in huge heavy luxurious vehicles. The raw materials of our food are produced by enormous machines in huge flat fields fertilised by the products of fossil fuel and then processed in huge factories. We use vast quantities of clean drinking water every day, most of which is flushed into the overloaded sewers. We buy vast quantities of cheap plastic gadgets which are sent to us in enormous ships and 30-wheel trucks and most of them are then sent to landfill where they will remain in our environment for centuries.
Even if every “democratic” country were run by Green parties, we would not see much change because what needs to be done goes against one of our deepest instincts – to “eat our future*”, to grab as many resources for ourselves as we can while they are there so that we can feed our children and grow our population. This is how all life has evolved. Other creatures hit limits and learn how to live within them. We use our vast brains to get round them.
Somehow, if we are to survive, we need to organise how we live in harmony with what is available to us not just now, but for the foreseeable future. Our economy must be based on what can be supplied rather than what we demand – what we would like. It would involve a substantial cut in our standard of living and it would have to be evenly shared across the world. I can’t see many people in the wealthy countries voting for that.
If you want some solid evidence with graphs and statistics about this I refer you to the Global Footprint Network. *See also “The Future Eaters” by Tim Flannery.
