One of my New Year Resolutions is to make better use of this website now that, thanks largely to local resident Jan Lucas, it has been restored. At a little gathering of neighbours in December one of the half-serious topics discussed over mulled wine and snacks was a local Philosophical Society.
The next morning, sober, it sounded pretentious, but we also discussed the threatened closure of the village church, and it struck me that a congregation is, in part, just that, and certainly Facebook can act as a kind of philosophical society, so I’m going to open a topic which has been on my mind for some time.
The Urban versus the Natural

Lisbon, September 2025: Urban
One of the more difficult directions my thoughts stray into is my antipathy to what I call “Urban” thinking. I see this is the product of several generations of people who have been brought up in the big wealthy cities of Europe, Australasia and North America without much contact with traditional non-urban ways of life in small communities. Their lives are densely connected by social media and “lifestyle” choices such as sports, exercise, fashion, food and entertainment. To many of them eating outside the home is normal; spending money on fashionable clothes, make-up, sports accessories, gadgets, exotic foods and so on is normal. They live in a polarised world of conspiracy theories and “isms” such as veganism, anti-racism, anti-sexism and trans-exclusionism.

Ambrieres Les Vallees, France, February 2025: Natural
The difficulty comes when we try to find a recognisable alternative to the Urban. “Rural” does not work. Living outside cities and towns is simply a geographical marker and does not describe a way of thinking. The word I prefer is “Natural” and there is one philosopher above all who typifies the radical end of the Natural spectrum: Wendell Berry, the scourge of the ills of American industrial society. People who live a Natural life need not be Nature freaks, they drive cars, go to supermarkets, send tons of plastic to landfill, but they live in contact with their communities and with tradition. If you ask one of them what a TERF is they would probably be mystified. To make sense of the term Natural as a recognisable way of being, it must include the full range of human experience, but the emphasis will be more on manual work than office work, more on outdoor living than indoor and especially more focussed on family and community than on transient fashion. It would be Natural to chat at the pub rather than the Water Cooler.
A Natural view of, for example, the “trans” debate would be that we should sympathise with anyone who has problems with their gender or sexuality, but that such things are the concern of a tiny minority and are not really important against the big issues of society such as war, poverty and climate change.
